Companies We Represent

Insurance Agency of Ohio

Auto-Owners Insurance logo: dark blue text on white, tagline
Safeco Insurance logo with the company name and Liberty Mutual branding.
Progressive Insurance logo in blue text on a white background.
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies logo: a blue bridge icon above the company name.
Philadelphia Insurance Companies logo: A blue square with a white Liberty Bell, beneath text.
Red CNA logo on a white background.
View more

Company Customer Service


Below are the insurance companies that Insurance Agency of Ohio partners with. We have provided direct links to their websites and customer service centers for your convenience. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us.

The Cincinnati Insurance Company

Logo for The Cincinnati Insurance Companies: blue bridge with company name below.

Customer Service Phone: (888) 242-8811

CNA

Red

Customer Service Phone: (800) CNA-2000

The Cincinnati Insurance Company


Customer Service Phone: (888) 242-8811

Main Website

Account Login

Download App

Pay Now


CNA


Customer Service Phone: (800) CNA-2000

Main Website

Account Login

Pay My Bill


Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Customer Service Phone: (877) 438-7459

Main Website

Account Login

Guest Bill Pay (ACH)

Credit Card Bill Pay


Progressive

Customer Service Phone: (833) 860-1309

Main Website

Account Login

Download App

Make a Payment


Safeco Insurance

Customer Service Phone: (800) 332-3226

Main Website

Account Login

Download App

Pay Your Bill


State Auto Insurance Companies

Customer Service Phone: (833) 724-3577

Main Website

Account Login

Download App

Pay My Bill


Travelers

Customer Service Phone: (800) 842-5075

Main Website

Account Login

Download App

Pay Your Bill


Auto Owners Insurance

Customer Service Phone: (888) 252-4626

Main Website

Account Login

Download App

Pay My Bill

Safeco Insurance

Safeco Insurance logo with blue and gray blocks and

Customer Service Phone: (800) 332-3226

Auto Owners Insurance

Auto-Owners Insurance logo with blue text, listing insurance types: Life, Home, Car, Business.

Customer Service Phone: (888) 252-4626

Ohio state outline with the letters

One of Central Ohio's Premier Insurance Agencies


We serve personal and business clients in Worthington, Ohio, Franklin County, Columbus, and the greater central Ohio area.


7100 N High Street, STE 300, Worthington, OH 43085


Phone: (380) 271-2660


Fax: (614) 848-7698


Columbus Business First: Insurance Agency of Ohio, ranked #11 on the 2024 list of largest central Ohio insurance agencies.